Great Financial Ideas Newsletter - April 2014

You are receiving this message because you are registered on our database as a client or contact. If you no longer wish to receive information from Parker Chartered Accountants + Financial Advisors you can unsubscribe at any time.


You may have seen in the March 2014 budget that HMRC’s consultation document on Tackling Marketed Tax Avoidance has passed to MP’s to consider as part of the next Finance Act. Although it is expected their proposals will be much watered down when they form part of the tax legislation I thought I would share my views on how the current proposals would play out if enacted in full.

What has HMRC proposed?

HMRC has proposed that companies that have undertaken tax avoidance strategies that have been registered under the DOTAS (Disclosure of Tax Avoidance Scheme) rules will now be expected to make a payment on account to HMRC. This payment on account will be repaid should the planning ultimately be found to work by the courts.
This is seen as unconstitutional on two counts, firstly the planning has not been tested by the courts and so unless a court says the planning does not work the tax is not due in the mind of most fair minded people. Secondly there is no right of appeal built into the system, so HMRC are judge and jury in their own court.

How this is likely to play out in practice

Bear in mind around 65,000 entities are thought to be affected by this legislation, most of which are represented by the country’s most successful entrepreneurs. These are not people who will agree to being bullied into paying tax that they have every reason to believe is not due. HMRC have already said they expect judicial review of the legislation. They have also said they expect it to take them two years plus to send out the assessments due to the sheer numbers involved. Whether any get paid is another matter.

What is not clear is whether HMRC can continue sending out demands whilst the actual legislation is under review. Neither is it clear whether taxpayers will be able to have their own circumstances dealt with under representative sample. As this new initiative is unprecedented it is expected the judiciary will not accept such an unconstitutional and cavalier approach to be taken by HMRC. At worst HMRC will find themselves being sued by tax payers should they act outside the law by enforcing payment of undue tax.
Many of the companies being targeted by HMRC will have no funds left and it is not clear what, if anything HMRC can or will do about this. The Inland Revenue must also be careful to ensure they too act within the law and only the courts will be able to decide this. Bearing in mind the tax courts are already creaking at the seams with cases the latest initiative will do nothing to alleviate this.

Andy Parker
Chartered Accountant and Chartered Financial Planner

Share your experiences
Add your own comments to any of the blogs that really strike a chord via the Parker website.

Maybe people perceive using wi-fi as less of a risk than using a traditional shared desktop PC with a wired connection, mostly seen in early years of Internet Cafes. But that’s really not the case. The security of mobile wifi hotspots is something you should think carefully about before logging on. Read more...
Changes announced in the budget make pensions investment more attractive than ever, especially for those over the age of 55. By making the most of the tax efficient features of pensions investment significant growth could be seen. Read more...
I came across this quote and it really stopped me in my tracks. As accountants we are usually the paragons of the realistic. However what Will Smith was getting at is being realistic is often an excuse for not pushing beyond our comfort zone and achieving much more than we first thought possible. Read more...
When I examine IT security failings the ‘corporate culture’ is often not properly aligned or suited to maintaining the ‘assets’ in the manner required or espoused by the security policy. This blog provides pointers on how you can embed a security culture in your business. Read more...
For advice on all accountancy and financial issues contact Parker Chartered Accountants and Financial Advisors on 0121 704 1354.


Andy Parker
Parker Chartered Accountants + Financial Advisors

If you wish to unsubscribe from this email please click here